Sugar Joined by Craig Finn, Patterson Hood, & Jason Narducy at Webster Hall

Sugar wrapped up their three-show reunion run at Webster Hall — their first shows in 31 years — on Monday night and played almost the exact same set as the two previous evenings. One difference: they had guests for the final three songs of the night.

Patterson Hood of Drive-By Truckers was first, coming out to help sing “JC Auto,” and then they brought out The Hold Steady ‘s Craig Finn to sing on “Helpless.” Finally they brought out Jason Narducy , who plays bass in Bob’s solo band, to sing on “If I Can’t Change Your Mind.” Watch video of all that below.

The only other difference in the set on Monday was they didn’t play “Gee Angel.” You can check out the Night 3 setlist below.

Bob Mould, David Barbe and Malcolm Travis have a few weeks off and then start their UK/EU tour in London on May 23. They’ll be back for a full North American tour with J Robbins as opener this fall, including another NYC show at Brooklyn Steel on October 16 which is Bob’s birthday.

You can also check our review of Night 1 , photos from Night 2 , and hear our conversation with Bob Mould about the reunion on BV Interviews .

> View this post on Instagram A post shared by Mick Lewis & The Fine Print (@themicklewis)

> View this post on Instagram A post shared by Mick Lewis & The Fine Print (@themicklewis)

SETLIST: Sugar @ Webster Hall 5/4/2026

The Act We Act

A Good Idea

Changes

Company Book

After All the Roads Have Led to Nowhere

In the Eyes of My Friends

Hoover Dam

Where Diamonds Are Halos

Running Out of Time

Gift

Your Favorite Thing

Clownmaster

Frustration

House of Dead Memories

Long Live Love

Panama City Motel

Can’t Help You Anymore

Fortune Teller

Anyone

Tilted

JC Auto (with Patterson Hood)

Helpless (with Craig Finn)

If I Can’t Change Your Mind (with Jason Narducy)

_Originally reported by [Brooklyn Vegan](https://www.brooklynvegan.com/sugar-brought-out-craig-finn-patterson-hood-jason-narducy-for-webster-hall-night-3-video/)._