Taylor Swift's "Cleveland!" Frenzy Recalls Paul McCartney's "Silly Love Songs" Impact

- Home - Music - Columns

Oct 1, 2026 3:44pm PT

There Is Precedent for Taylor Swift’s ‘Cleveland!’ Making the World Go Crazy: Paul McCartney’s ‘Silly Love Songs’ Era

By Chris Willman

Plus Icon

Chris Willman

Senior Music Writer and Chief Music Critic

ChrisWillman

Latest

- Laura Benanti on Her Journey From Broadway to Stand-Up With a Riotous One-Woman Show, ‘Nobody Cares,’ and Why Melania Remains One of Her Proudest Roles 22 hours ago

- Paul McCartney and Judd Apatow Have a Revealing and Free-Wheeling Conversation About Wings and the Beatles in ‘Man on the Run’ Post-Screening Q&A 2 days ago

- John Mayer Sets Sphere Residency for Spring 2027, Combining Full Band, Trio and Solo Sets 3 days ago

See All

- - - - - -

- - - - - - -

It is a controversy actually worthy of an exclamation point. When was the last time the internet lost its collective stuff over a single song the way it did this past week with Taylor Swift ‘s “Cleveland!”? And they say there’s no such thing as a monoculture anymore. It might have felt like everyone you knew had not only heard “Cleveland!” (unlike the millions of people coming onto X to proudly proclaim their unfamiliarity with “Choosin’ Texas” as ot busted chart records) but had a Very Hot Take on it. In the realm of her fandom, much of that discourse was defense of the track. But inherent in all that was the idea that the song needed defending. Because at the tip of this social tsunami was a strong supposition that swiftly powered a gazillion Instagram memes:

Related Stories

Rob Reiner Remembered as 'Our Beloved Meathead' and 'Cherished Legend' by Teary Jamie Lee Curtis in Emmys' In Memoriam

_Originally reported by [Variety Music](https://variety.com/2026/music/columns/taylor-swift-cleveland-controversy-paul-mccartney-1236894962/)._